Paige DeSorbo Says She Tried Her Summer House’s Costar Lindsay Hubbard’s Breast Milk: ‘We Loved It’

One Summer House cast member is “obsessed” with Lindsay Hubbard’s new motherhood journey — including Hubbard’s breast milk.

Paige DeSorbo recently revealed during her Amazon Livestream on Wednesday, Feb. 5, that she tasted her Summer House costar Hubbard’s breast milk, confessing that she even prefers it over other types of milk.

Hubbard, 38, announced the birth of her daughter Gemma Britt Kufe on Dec. 8, 2024. She shares the nearly two-month-old baby with her boyfriend, Turner Kufe.

During DeSorbo’s livestream, one streamer proposed in the comment section that DeSorbo put vegan oat milk in her espresso martinis, but DeSorbo instantly rejected the idea. She’s an “OG cow milk” drinker, and she prefers that over oat milk, she said.

DeSorbo, 32, would prefer trying different types of milk, even her friend’s breast milk.

“Actually, for the first time — this is a little bit too much information — one of my friends, my good friend Lindsay Hubbard, had a baby, and I tried her breast milk for the first time,” she explained.

“I’m not gonna lie, I’d throw that in my coffee before I’d throw oat milk in my coffee,” she said. “I was obsessed with it. I don’t know if you guys have ever tried someone’s breast milk before… so sweet. Honestly, it did taste like oat milk because it was so sweet, but I was obsessed with it. So, I would switch that in my espresso martini. Not going to lie.”

One user said they were surprised that DeSorbo tried Hubbard’s breast milk because of their inconsistent friendship on the Bravo series. However, DeSorbo said she was obsessed with Hubbard’s pregnancy and is obsessed with Hubbard’s infant daughter, Gemma.

DeSorbo explained that she tried the milk when she met Gemma for the first time and Hubbard was pumping. “I was like, ‘Put a little in a shot glass for your girl! I wanna try it,’” DeSorbo recalled. “And she had never tried it either. I was like, ‘Are you kidding? We’re trying it!’ So, we tried it, and we loved it.”

Hubbard, a former publicist, announced her pregnancy in a July 4 social media post. Her pregnancy was documented for the upcoming season of Summer House.

Hubbard spoke with PEOPLE in late December about navigating motherhood and living apart from Gemma’s father. Despite their living arrangement, she told PEOPLE that “he has spent the night and has been by my side 24/7 for the entire past month.”

“And even though technically this is my apartment, this is our HQ for the home of our daughter and me,” Hubbard told PEOPLE. “He basically brought over a bunch of clothes and toiletries and is essentially going between my apartment and his apartment, but rarely ever leaves me and Gemma.”

“If there’s anything that I’ve learned from my past, especially in my last relationship, it’s that nothing is guaranteed,” she said, referencing her previous engagement to Summer House costar Carl Radke. “And when you get pregnant so quickly into dating, I didn’t want to put more pressure on our relationship than a pregnancy and a baby is already putting that — very big, lifelong pressure.”